That everyone fails to realize one thing. One very, very, important thing.
Teams don’t take the best player available. And if they are, they’re idiots. Most teams take the best player ON THEIR BOARD.
Does anyone understand this? There is no way to grade the dratfts of the teams unless you know all of their systems. If you know how the team does things and what they’re looking for and who’s going to fit their system and who isn’t, then please grade away.
Otherwise, shut up.
I’m tired of people complaining that their ‘team’ has made a bad pick when they have no clue what they’re talking about.
Let’s look at the Colts, probably the team that drafts the best in the NFL. Year in and year out they rely on their draft picks to make their team. They don’t sign big free agents. Okay, maybe Vinatieri but he’s the sole one.
This year the Colts selected a center with their first pick. Oh no they have all-pro Jeff Saturday! What are they doing!? Well, they’re creating depth and are prepared if Saturday retires or his play declines.
Oh no, the Patriots wasted a third on a QB!? They have Brady! They need offensive line! Look, with the pass rush the Giants brought in the Super Bowl, no one was going to block that. They have Brady, and Brady is 30. Cassell is a free agent and the end of the year and is not a good backup (remember when he almost blew that game againt Miami and Brady had to come back in?), and who knows, maybe O’Connell will take over for Brady in five years.
Please, just stop talking. There’s a reason your team passed on that player you wanted. They were concerned! Either they didn’t think he fit the system, he wouldn’t be able to grasp the system, he has bad character, he’s not intelligent, or they just like the other guy better. Teams aren’t missing picks on purpose. They spend months doing this. They work their assess off.
The bigges reason a bust turns out bad is because either they weren’t able to develop him into an NFL player, the player just couldn’t do it, the surrounding teammates couldn’t help him out, or the player just messed up so much the team gave up on him.
So please, during the 2009 draft. Wait, be patient, and try to understand why you picked your players. After they play, after they make the team, then talk about whether they were a good pick or not.